Question:
How does the presumption of marriage validity impact legal proceedings involving competing claims of marriage (e.g., multiple spouses)?
Answer:
In Texas, when there are competing claims of marriage—for example, a previous marriage not formally dissolved and a subsequent marriage entered into in good faith—the presumption of validity applies to the most recent marriage.
This rule is especially important in bigamy cases, estate claims, or benefit disputes. Here’s how it works:
-
If Party A was previously married to Party B but never finalized a divorce and later married Party C, Texas law presumes the most recent marriage (to Party C) is valid.
-
The burden is on anyone challenging that newer marriage to prove that the earlier marriage was never legally dissolved and that no valid divorce occurred.
This legal presumption:
-
Protects innocent parties in the second marriage who may be unaware of defects in the prior union
-
Stabilizes estate claims, preventing long-lost spouses from disrupting inheritance or insurance claims
-
Prevents abuse of technicalities that might otherwise be used to invalidate a marriage after the fact
Ultimately, the presumption of validity reflects a policy choice to favor settled expectations and relationships unless compelling, legally recognized grounds exist for invalidation.
If you’re litigating or advising on a marriage validity issue in Texas, you’ll want to:
-
Carefully review Chapter 6 of the Family Code
-
Confirm the existence or absence of prior marriages and divorces
-
Gather documents showing good-faith intent and compliance with statutory procedures
And when challenging or defending a marriage’s validity, remember: the burden of proof is high, and the law is designed to shield marriages—not tear them down—unless the facts clearly warrant it.